Gurnsey Hollow Cemetery, Frewsburg, New York - Discussion
Anonymous
· Oct. 30, 2025, 1:36 a.m.
Discussion thread for Gurnsey Hollow Cemetery, Frewsburg, New York.
Gurnsey Hollow Cemetery has gravesites that date back to the 1800s and a tragic story to boot. Legend has it that long ago, a mentally handicapped girl, age 7, was stoned to death here by a gang of townsfolk. The reason for the witch hunt is unknown. Her body is said to be buried here, and...
Share your experiences, theories, and questions about this location!