12 Gay Street, New York, New York - Discussion
Anonymous
· Oct. 30, 2025, 5:09 a.m.
Discussion thread for 12 Gay Street, New York, New York.
It's a historic brick townhouse, built in 1827, and it was once a speakeasy called Pirate's Den. So of course, it has to have a ghost! The townhouse has been home to former New York City mayor Jimmy Walker and Howdy Doody puppet designer Frank Paris. The ghost's identity is not certain, but...
Share your experiences, theories, and questions about this location!